I love this cartoon from Natalie Dee on fanpop.com

Before Christmas I got my TYs (over 50 of them) and my Leaving Certs to write personal essays. Their essays for the most part were funny, sad, moving, at times mad and in many cases very very brave. Among other things I read about a childhood obsession with goldfish; a superhero granny; being an only child; falling into a river in front of the boy you absolutely love love love; suicide; a haunted church; spontaneous uncontrollable crying spells; and being wrapped in tin foil and carried off a volleyball court on a stretcher…

I also discovered that “a commode is the love child of a wheelchair and a portaloo!

I did notice however that very occasionally a personal essay didn’t ‘ring true‘. It’s hard for me to explain how I knew that the writer was inventing or embellishing a sad story (leaning towards or sometimes completely inventing a fiction) rather than drawing on real life experiences (fact) but when I asked a couple of students about it sure enough they said what they’d written about hadn’t actually happened but they felt compelled to give the personal essay a tragic ending in order to engage the reader emotionally.

Oddly, it had the opposite effect – I enjoyed these essays up to the point where they transformed into melodrama and then I just somehow knew that the writer was trying to force a reaction out of me.

Have a look at this beautiful personal essay – but be warned:

(1) It will make you cry

and

(2) You could never write this. You are not a thirty-something-yr-old widower with a toddler and a dead wife. You are a 17 or 18yr old Irish leaving cert student and this is the perspective you MUST write from when you write a personal essay in the exams because fundamentally a personal essay IS NOT A SHORT STORY and IS NOT FICTION. Of course you can write about something funny that happened to someone else and pretend it happened to you; of course you can exaggerate for dramatic or humorous effect. But try to write what you know or your essay is in danger of coming across as insincere and false.

Here it is: http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2013/jan/19/telling-toddler-mummys-dead?CMP=twt_gu

Now have a look at this personal essay, whose tone is much more philosophical and opinionated rather than emotional – the tone is completely different but there is no question that it also falls into the category of personal essay.

Here it is (with the longest url in the history of life the universe and everything):

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/education/an-a-student-regrets-his-grades/article7359620/?cmpid=rss1&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed:%20TheGlobeAndMail-National%20%28The%20Globe%20and%20Mail%20-%20National%20News%29&buffer_share=8b014

I guess I just want you to realise that you can write a serious opinion piece; an emotional admission; or a funny satire and ALL will still qualify as ‘personal essays’ as long as you write in the first person (“I”) and as long as you are yourself (Irish teenager) not a fictional narrator (a witchdoctor, a talking rubbish bin or a homeless wino).

For clarification of the difference between the personal essay and memoir check this out: http://meghanward.com/blog/2012/08/21/personal-essay-vs-memoir/

That’s all for now folks. Good luck with the mocks revision!

 

7 Responses to Tone (personal essay)

  1. orla drumgoole says:

    Thanks for this Evelyn! Ties in nicely with class tomorrow!

  2. Veronica says:

    I am a mum of 2 leaving cert students, and find your notes so helpful Evelyn. Go raibh mile maith agat!

  3. Alice Myers says:

    Hello Evelyn….thank you very much for all of this fantastic advice .I have a question that I hope you can help with.
    I am an adult learner sitting the leaving cert this year 2013 …I have just read the section on writing a personal essay and note you advise
    …….. “You are a 17 or 18yr old Irish leaving cert student and this is the perspective you MUST write from when you write a personal essay in the exams”

    I intend writing with my own voice and from my own perspective but wonder if this will confuse marker or work against me ?

    • Hi Alice,
      Absolutely you must write as yourself. In the essay section you can choose to write an article, a speech, a short story or a personal essay.
      For the first three – article, speech, short story (which by the way is for most people the hardest to score highly on) – it doesn’t really matter if you write as yourself or take on a persona (unless the question specifies of course).
      For the personal essay, you’ll have a fresh perspective on things as someone with life experience coming back to education. I think this will work to your advantage. If possible (and of course it depends on the topic) you might be able to work that in to the essay somewhere?
      eg. “If you’d have told me 5 years ago I’d be back sitting the leaving, I’d have laughed in your faceorThere are three things I’m proud of in my life – my —-, my —- and my decision at —- years of age to re-sit the leaving cert“. Like I said it really depends what the essay question is.
      If you can’t work it in, don’t force it. Chances are the examiner will figure it out from other things you say if you choose the personal essay that you’re not a teenager.
      Hope that helps!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *