I’ve found myself thinking about plagiarism a lot since I started this website. There’s not much confusion about what it is – taking someone else’s language, thoughts, ideas or expressions and passing them off as your own – but there seems to be no consensus anymore as to whether or not it’s ok. Particularly when it comes to the leaving cert.

The major problem lies in the sheer volume of information your average teenager is expected to hold in their brain in order to sit this exam. If the teacher doesn’t provide a no nonsense, here are the essentials, forget about real learning synopsis of every aspect of the course, students and parents will look elsewhere. And who can really blame them? If it’s possible to fake knowledge and understanding and thus achieve an impressive set of results and entry into your college course of choice, why wouldn’t you? If there’s one thing we know about human beings, it is this. We do what works. If there’s a shortcut, we’ll take it.

So does rote learning work? In the short term, possibly, and it really depends on the subject. In the long term, not at all. You’ll go to college and suddenly independent thinking, critical analysis, originality and initiative are all expected of you. In fact I frequently hear college lecturers bemoan the months of effort they have to put into de-programming first year college students from the rote learning that has become second nature to them in secondary school. My focus on turning my students into better writers sometimes drives them to utter despair but a robotic ability to learn off reams of facts is not something I can ever or will ever view as anything but pointless.

There is no easy solution. Continuous assessment is wide open to plagiarism – you get your uncle the carpenter to do your woodwork project and voila, you’ve got an A. Reforming college entry is an obvious starting point – if you take away the points race, you remove the pressure on students and teachers to teach/learn to the test – but this solution is also riddled with problems. How else do you decide who gets into college? A lottery? Finally, reducing the number of subjects students study seems an obvious step forward, but is it right to narrow their exposure to the world of knowledge and ideas so early? And will students again just choose the ‘easy’ options? We already have a massive problem with a lack of uptake in Maths, Science and IT. Do we really want to make things worse?

As for English as a subject, 75% of the Junior Cert and 55% of the Leaving Cert you will not see until you turn over and read the exam papers. You can rote learn until the cows moo loudly at dawn but if you don’t twist what you’ve learned to suit the question you will not do well. And most importantly of all, you must be able to write well. Perhaps years of sample answers you’ve been encouraged to learn off do you the greatest disservice of all, because they undermine your opportunities to practise constructing clear coherent sentences of your own.

Finally, be aware that Ruairi Quinn has recently been quoted critiquing our fondness for predictable exam papers that don’t require students to think laterally, apply knowledge or demonstrate understanding. I think in coming years the exam papers will get less predictable. Whilst that makes me feel sorry for those of you desperate to get into your chosen college course, on some level it does make more sense to offer a genuine challenge. If only the stakes weren’t so high, I’d feel more supportive of it.

 

Tagged with:
 

4 Responses to Topic of the Week: Plagiarism

  1. Viveth says:

    Damn it Ruairi, why do you only start feeling like making the JC and LC unpredictable now?? Can’t it wait another year until you make getting into college impossible for us??

    – A disappointed, gloomy student about to take the mock exams on Monday.

    • Oh dear, please don’t feel gloomy. I’ve been reminding my students lately how many wonderful things in life there are which have absolutely nothing to do with how you do in the Leaving. Who you fall in love with; how many countries you get to visit; how many beautiful children (or not) you have; the inventions you might yet create; the many flavours of ice-cream you get to sample in a lifetime. So so many wonderful things await you. When I was stressed in Leaving Cert one day my mam gave me a pile of old plates, a plastic bag and a dustpan and brush. She told me to go down the road and smash all the plates and I’d stop feeling so stressed (but I had to sweep them up after of course!). It worked. If you can source some old plates tomorrow go for it. Very cathartic! Best of luck with the mocks!

  2. […] and cheating are a problem that as teachers we just know we are going to have to deal with. In the Topic of the Week on leavingcertenglish.net, talks not about why it is such a problem but more about how secondary […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *